One Of Us Is Guilty Audiobook

Five Friends. One Murder. Everyone has a secret.

In the serene paradise of the Florida Keys, five women meet for a cozy book club night. But when their playful discussion about the “perfect” murder turns terrifyingly real, their lives take a dark and twisted turn. The next morning, a mutual enemy is found dead—killed in a way that mirrors their innocent musings.

Suddenly, the line between fiction and reality blurs. One of them has taken their “joke” too far, turning their friends into unwitting pawns in a deadly game. Now, with the police closing in and suspicion tearing their friendships apart, they must race against time to find the real killer among them before they’re all implicated in a crime they didn't commit… or did they?

Secrets are exposed, alliances are shattered, and as tensions rise, they begin to wonder if faith is their only way out. In a tale of chilling suspense, deceit, and betrayal, discover what happens when the darkest parts of a person are pushed to the surface.

Perfect for fans of clean and wholesome mysteries, gripping thrillers, and Christian suspense, One of Us Is Guilty will keep you guessing until the final, heart-stopping twist.

Emily Harris adjusted the plate of lemon bars on her coffee table and glanced at the clock. Five minutes until the others would arrive for their afternoon book club. She smoothed the pages of the mystery novel they’d just finished and drew a deep breath. The book club had been her lifeline since David’s death last year—a small circle of friendship in a world that had suddenly grown too large and empty for her and twelve-year-old Luke.

Thirteen months had passed since the accident, yet some days the grief still felt raw enough to steal her breath. David had been her high school sweetheart, her confidant, her partner in building this life in the Florida Keys—a life that now felt like a half-finished painting.

What had begun as a desperate attempt to connect with others had become unexpectedly meaningful: five women from different backgrounds brought together by a shared love of stories—and perhaps by something deeper Emily couldn’t quite name.

Emily made a mental note to thank Mrs. Rodriguez for the extra cleaning work she'd done earlier that week. The house felt spotless, though she couldn't shake the feeling that something was slightly different - furniture positioned just a bit differently than she remembered. The doorbell chimed, jolting her from her thoughts.

“Coming!” she called, tucking a strand of chestnut hair behind her ear.

Vanessa Reed stood at the door, impeccably dressed in a cream linen dress that somehow hadn’t wrinkled in the humid Florida air. She held a bottle of pinot grigio in one hand and her designer purse in the other.

“Emily, darling,” Vanessa said, stepping inside with a confident stride. “I hope I’m not too early. Martin was driving me crazy with his business calls, and I simply had to escape.”

“You’re right on time,” Emily replied with a smile, accepting the wine. “How are things with Martin?”

A shadow crossed Vanessa’s perfectly made-up face before she waved her hand dismissively. “Oh, you know how men are with their work. Always some crisis or another.”

Before Emily could respond, the doorbell rang again. This time, Claire Thompson and Natalie Clark stood at the threshold.

“We carpooled,” Claire explained, her salt-and-pepper hair framing a kind face lined with the wisdom of her fifty years. She held a tray of chocolate chip cookies. “Fresh from the oven.”

Natalie nodded, her expression as reserved as always. At thirty-five, she was the youngest in their group, and often the quietest. “I brought sparkling water,” she said, holding up two bottles. “For those of us who are driving.”

“Perfect,” Emily said, ushering them inside. “Beth texted she’s running a few minutes late. Something about Sophia’s homework.”

The women settled into Emily’s living room, a cozy space decorated with bookshelves and family photographs. Through the window, palm trees swayed beneath a pastel evening sky—the signature of the Florida Keys that had drawn Emily here after David’s death. A fresh start. A peaceful place to heal.

Ten minutes later, Beth Collins rushed in, her blonde hair disheveled, dark circles under her eyes.

“I’m so sorry,” she said, setting down a plate of store-bought brownies. “Sophia had a meltdown over her algebra assignment, and then the car wouldn’t start, and—” She stopped abruptly, noticing everyone watching her. “Anyway, I’m here now.”

Emily studied her friend with concern. Beth had always been high-strung, but lately, she seemed perpetually on edge. “Everything okay, Beth? You look exhausted.”

“Fine,” Beth said too quickly. “Just the usual single mom chaos. Nothing I can’t handle.”

Vanessa poured wine for herself, Emily, and Claire, while Natalie and Beth opted for sparkling water.

“Well,” Emily said, settling into her armchair, “what did everyone think of The Perfect Alibi? I have to say, I didn’t see that twist coming.”

“In real life, the obvious suspect is rarely the guilty one.” Vanessa added, gesturing with her wine glass. There’s always some unexpected twist.”

Claire sipped her wine thoughtfully. “I found it a bit far-fetched, honestly. The detective missed so many obvious clues just to build suspense.”

“That’s what I love about these books,” Vanessa said. “They’re completely unrealistic. In real life, murders are messy, impulsive. Not these elaborately planned schemes.”

“And you know this from personal experience?” Natalie raised an eyebrow.

The women laughed, breaking the tension that had lingered since Beth’s arrival.

“I’m just saying,” Vanessa continued, “all these ‘perfect murder’ plots—they’d never work in real life. Someone always slips up.”

“I don’t know,” Emily mused. “The author made a good point about evidence being planted or manipulated. If someone were meticulous enough…”

Beth’s hand trembled slightly as she reached for a cookie. Emily noticed but chose not to comment.

“Let’s play a game,” Claire suggested suddenly. “If you were writing a mystery, how would your character commit the perfect murder?”

“Claire!” Natalie looked scandalized. “You’re a church volunteer!”

Claire chuckled. “It’s just hypothetical, dear. No need to call the pastor.”

Vanessa leaned forward, her eyes sparkling with interest. “I’ll start. If I were plotting the perfect murder, I’d make it look like an accident. A tampered brake line, perhaps. Clean, efficient, and nearly impossible to trace.”

“That’s disturbing,” Natalie said, though she looked intrigued. “I suppose I’d go with something untraceable. A poison that mimics natural causes.”

“Like what happened to that Russian spy?” Emily asked.

“Exactly,” Natalie nodded. “Though I’d be more subtle. Maybe something that looked like a heart attack.”

“Beth?” Claire prompted. “What’s your method?”

Beth startled, nearly spilling her water. “What? Oh, I don’t know. I haven’t thought about it.”

“Come on,” Vanessa teased. “Everyone’s fantasized about eliminating someone.” She winked to show she was joking, but Beth didn’t smile.

“Fine,” Beth said after a moment. “I’d use an untraceable sedative, then stage a drowning. We’re surrounded by water, after all.”

The room fell silent.

“That’s… specific,” Natalie said slowly.

Beth’s face flushed. “You asked! Besides, it’s just hypothetical.”

“My turn,” Claire said cheerfully. “I’d use someone else’s method and frame them. Let them take the fall while I walk free.”

“Claire!” Emily laughed. “And here I thought you were the saint among us.”

Claire’s eyes twinkled. “Even saints have imagination, dear.”

Emily tapped her chin thoughtfully. “I think I’d create an elaborate alibi—something public and verifiable—then hire someone else to do the deed.”

“A hitman?” Vanessa exclaimed. “Emily Harris, our quiet English teacher!”

“It’s foolproof,” Emily defended with a smile. “No physical evidence linking me to the crime.”

“Alright,” Claire said, suddenly serious. “Let’s make this more interesting. Who would you use your method on? Someone who truly deserves it.”

A heavy silence fell over the room. The game no longer felt so lighthearted. 

Vanessa spoke first. “Tom Edwards,” she said, her voice hard. “That man ruined my father’s life with his investment scam. Dad never recovered.”

Emily blinked in surprise. She knew Vanessa’s father had lost money in a bad investment, but Vanessa had never named names before.

Natalie nodded slowly. “I’d have to agree. Edwards is… problematic.”

“You know him?” Vanessa asked sharply.

“By reputation,” Natalie replied coolly. “I'm consulting for his firm now. Let’s just say his ethics are questionable at best.”

“What about you, Claire?” Emily asked, hoping Claire would have a more lighthearted answer.

Claire sighed. “If we’re being honest, probably Richard Kane. He’s been trying to shut down the shelter where I volunteer. Claims it drags down property values in his precious neighborhood.”

“Beth?” Emily prompted gently.

Beth looked down at her hands. “David Hoffman,” she said quietly. “My ex-boss. He’s been… making things difficult since I left the company.”

Emily frowned. “I didn’t know you were having trouble with him.”

“It’s nothing,” Beth said quickly. “Just… work stuff.”

“And you, Emily?” Claire asked.

Emily hesitated. For a fleeting moment, the face of her husband’s best friend flashed in her mind—the man who’d been driving the night David died. The man who’d walked away unscathed, while David had been killed instantly. The man whose version of the accident had never quite added up.

“Just a fictional character,” she said lightly. “No one real.”

The women looked at her skeptically but didn’t press. 

“Well,” Claire said, checking her watch, “this took a dark turn. Perhaps we should discuss the actual book.”

The conversation drifted back to the novel, but an undercurrent of tension remained. Beth kept checking her phone, her expression growing more anxious. Vanessa drank more wine than usual. Natalie watched everyone with calculating eyes.

As the evening wound down, Beth was the first to leave, claiming Sophia would be waiting up for her.

“Is she okay?” Claire asked after the door closed. “She seems… on edge.”

“Probably just stressed,” Vanessa suggested. “It can’t be easy raising a teenager alone.”

Emily wasn’t so sure. She’d known Beth for over a year, and tonight something felt off—more than usual.

After everyone left around five o’clock, Emily cleaned up the living room, her thoughts replaying the afternoon’s unusual conversation. With Luke sleeping over at a friend’s, the house felt especially quiet.

She was loading the dishwasher when her phone chimed with a text from an unknown number.

The plan is in motion.

Emily frowned, staring at the message. What plan? Was this a wrong number?

She was about to text back when another message appeared.

Don’t act innocent. You all wanted this.

A chill ran down her spine. She set the phone down as if it had burned her and took a step back.

A practical joke, she told herself. It had to be. Probably Vanessa after too much wine.

Emily tried to sleep but found herself tossing and turning. The strange text messages and Beth’s odd behavior plagued her thoughts. When she finally drifted off, her dreams were filled with faceless figures and whispered threats.

The shrill ring of her phone jolted her awake at 6:17 a.m. Groggily, she reached for it.

“Emily?” Vanessa’s voice was tight with panic. “Have you seen the news?”

“News? No, I just woke up—”

“It’s Tom Edwards,” Vanessa cut in. “He’s dead. They found his body this morning. Emily… he drowned in his pool.”

Emily bolted upright, suddenly wide awake. “What?”

“They’re saying he was sedated first,” Vanessa whispered. “Just like Beth described last night.”

The room seemed to tilt as the implications sank in. Their hypothetical conversation. The mysterious texts. And now, a man was dead—murdered in a way they had casually discussed just hours before.

“Emily?” Vanessa’s voice sounded distant. “Are you there?”

“Yes,” Emily managed to say, her mouth dry. “I’m here.”

“What do we do?”

Emily thought of the mysterious texts from the night before and pulled the phone from her ear to look at them.

The plan is in motion.

She placed the phone back to her ear to continue the conversation.

“I don’t know,” she whispered. “I honestly don’t know.”

“Emergency meeting. My house. One hour. No excuses,” Vanessa declared before hanging up.

📓 Purchase eBook

📩 Receive download link via email from BookFunnel *Check spam

📲 Send to preferred reading device or read in BookFunnel app